The old comms advice that it’s never the original scandal that gets you, it’s the cover-up, has never felt truer as we watch cricket’s Sandpapergate1 reignite. This is the incident in which the Australian team were caught ball-tampering in a match back in 2018, roughing up the ball with sandpaper to gain an unfair advantage. Australians, cricket fans and those with a passing interest in the human side of scandal look on at the drama continues to play out like a bizarre reality TV show, to the detriment of pretty much all involved and casting a shadow on the sport itself.
Watching from afar, with passing experience of human nature and knowing some of the acts in the cover-up drama, some things appear to be true and don’t require specialist cricket knowledge. Four in particular cast doubt on the accepted wisdom of events.
I’ve learned the hard way how not facing up to issues in the moment and handling them as they arise, regardless of the pain at the time, instead serves to prolong the pain. This is what the comms advisors teach in a corporate context. It seems to me that if the truth had come out in 2018, however painful and whatever the consequences, there would be no more story to tell in 2026. Therefore something is amiss. The wound wasn’t effectively cleaned and it continues to fester. Whatever the punishment and its impact on individuals, the team, Cricket Australia and the wider game, it would be served by now. We would have moved on.
It’s also human nature to try and to use words to thread the needle and hide the truth. We see examples all the time – personal relationships at home, team issues at work. Here’s the opening line of the rebuttal statement2 released by the four bowlers in 2021, three years into this drama: “We did not know a foreign substance was taken onto the field to alter the condition of the ball until we saw the images on the big screen at Newlands”. This doesn’t say they weren’t aware of the plan to do this, just that they didn’t know it was being enacted at that point in time. If the statement had been bolder and more definitive, we may have all moved on. This ability to hold to a truth, but not necessarily the truth, is a form of ethical fading3 whereby self-deception allows one to behave in your own self interest while, at the same time, falsely believing that one’s moral principles were upheld.
Then there is always the issue of who pays the price. In a team environment and things go wrong it is rarely (but can be) the failings of a rogue individual. Yet how many times does the team collectively accept responsibility and how often is someone scapegoated? We individualise the punishment for what is a collective or systemic failure, often shifting the blame onto someone who wasn’t ultimately responsible. After the scandal at Stafford Hospital4 which saw excess deaths in the 2000s, individual staff were disciplined and vilified in the press, while the Francis Inquiry concluded the real causes were systemic: cost-cutting targets, weak regulatory oversight, and a culture of fear imposed from the top. Accountability generally attaches to whoever is visible, junior, or dispensable, while diffuse leadership structures escape scrutiny. Visible in this instance are the captain and vice-captain; junior and dispensable, the player caught stuffing the sandpaper down his trousers, playing in his 8th match5 for Australia (he’s only played two more since, and not since 2019). It’s clear who the scapegoats were.
When a major incident or scandal breaks, whether at home or at work, it’s human nature to gather as a team or a group to gossip and chat and speculate about what’s been going on and what happens next. Whether it’s the sudden resignation of a chief executive, the loss of a major contract or a local crisis, if you’re affected you can’t avoid it. It’s hard not to imagine the whole team sitting in the dressing room and talking after the day’s play6, probably for some time, figuring out what went on, what it means, and what next. Sometimes the group reaches consensus, sometimes not. In serious cases that escalate someone senior always determines the course of action.
These four insights alone raise the distinct possibility that the whole thing’s been a classic corporate cover-up. Not only would the issue have been resolved if openly addressed at the time, but we have the bowlers’ statement that can be read as true in a literal sense while also being short of the truth; the scapegoating of three players in what is a tightly-knit team sport; differences of opinion over any discussion and conversation as a team afterwards in what points to be a classic ‘get the story straight’ move.
But why bother covering it up? Perhaps it is a simple as following the incentives. Players coming out more vocally once they are retired aren’t going to have their career prospects harmed by the truth, even though they have a book to sell. Bowlers still bowling are going to want to hold the line, whether right or wrong, and preserve their records and reputations (which are significant in the case of the four signatories to the 2021 statement). Administrators want to preserve revenue, especially sponsorship, which always takes a hit when reputations are tarnished, and never more so than when one of the main protagonists is the current captain.
We’re now seeing a moral dilemma play out for each individual associated with team on that day. Those who find themselves in these situations face difficult and sometimes life-changing choices, in the classic whistleblower’s dilemma. Dr. Stephen Bolsin7, for example, was a consultant anaesthetist at Bristol Royal Infirmary who spent years trying to raise the alarm8 about unusually high death rates in children’s heart surgery. He was marginalised, obstructed, and effectively hounded out of British medicine before the 1998 GMC inquiry finally vindicated him. He did everything by the book – raised concerns through proper channels, repeatedly, for years, yet the system punished him for it while promoting those he complained about.
This also shows us what to look for next – the cover up of the cover up. It’s a natural escalation that is the only way to try and control the story, and this often involves attempts to discredit the whistleblowers or dissenting voices through disinformation and deflection. When there’s little or no evidence for the first there may be evidence for subsequent moves; if sandpapergate escalates it might reveal the original plan in its shadow.
How does this end? If we learn anything about cover-ups in our corporate and personal contexts, we know that even though the answers are rarely black and white in a situation like this, because different people would have been involved to different degrees, ultimately the truth will out. The truth in this situation might prematurely end four storied careers before next year’s Ashes series and throw Cricket Australia into administrative turmoil, or it might vindicate the official version of events and cast a shadow on those suggesting otherwise. Only time will tell.
I know how hard situations like this can feel, caught in really tricky situations to navigate. Sure, we can try and hide it, ducking for cover kiss-cam-style9, or play it down and hope it goes away. Alternatively we can own it, recognising that openness and honesty are virtues worth the short-term pain, even if they seem in short supply at times. There’s a reason why the Nolan principles10 of public life stand the test of time; it’s the least we expect of our public officials11 and, in different contexts, the least we expect of those with high profile positions in society.
2 https://www.cricket.com.au/news/3313194
4 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stafford_Hospital_scandal
6 https://www.bbc.co.uk/sport/cricket/articles/c9ly4jm8djy7o
7 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stephen_Bolsin
8 http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/health/1218149.stm
9 https://metro.co.uk/2026/07/16/coldplay-kiss-cam-scandal-happened-a-year-ago-still-not-29154946/
11 Even as we see these principles increasingly fraying around the edges

Leave a Reply